The electoral college ensures that all parts of the country are involved in selecting the president of the united states if the election depended solely on the popular vote, then candidates could limit campaigning to heavily-populated areas or specific regions. Electoral college, the system by which the president and vice president of the united states are chosen it was devised by the framers of the united states constitution to provide a method of election that was feasible, desirable, and consistent with a republican form of government. One interesting twist to the arguments raised by electoral college critics focuses on the reality that even if small states benefit from the electoral college, they do so at the expense of the.
A related argument in favor of the electoral college is that it isolates vote recounts to one or a few states rather than the entire nation imagine the 2000 florida recount fiasco on a national level, say the supporters of the electoral college. The electoral college should be abolished for the reason that it is an undemocratic system the united states, and all other nations should strive for a more democratic system this is supported by the following arguments. The united states does not elect its presidents by a popular vote, but instead uses an electoral college process to select its leader, which may not be the politicians a majority of voters favored the most recent example occurred in 2000 when al gore won the popular vote, but george w bush earned. The electoral college - this paper will take an in depth look at how the voting process works in the united states, but mainly focus on the electoral college and its wrongs and rights in the american voting system.
If the amount of electoral college votes a state receives was directly proportionate to its population, smaller rural states would be rendered completely irrelevant. There is no constitutional argument in favor of abolishing the electoral college considering that article ii, section 1 of the constitution is what gives us this system in the first place it lays out all of the specifics on how it will work by detailing numbers, the locations where the electors shall meet, and how the voting process should work. Abolishing the electoral college completely would require a constitutional amendment, involving two-thirds approval from both houses of congress and approval by 38 states—a process very unlikely.
The electoral college restores some of the weight in the political balance that large states (by population) lose by virtue of the mal-apportionment of the senate decreed in the constitution. If democracy means the majority rules, the electoral college is an undemocratic institution twice in the last five elections it has delivered the white house to the loser of the popular vote. Core arguments for the electoral college are based on faulty premises the electoral college violates political equity and popular choice, but doesn't provide any compensatory benefits. If anything, it was the electoral college that made it possible to end slavery, since abraham lincoln earned only 39 percent of the popular vote in the election of 1860, but won a crushing victory. The pro's and con's of the electoral college system offer very powerful arguments in its favor no serious proposals to abolish the united states senate on.
Peter k clarke - 10/9/2007 the electoral college is an anachronism, but it provides the minor side benefit that otherwise lazy americans, especially in the news media, are forced to learn a. Because abolishing the current system will strongly tilt elections in favor of candidates who can win huge electoral margins in the country's major metropolitan areas. Abolishing the electoral college completely would require a constitutional amendment, involving two-thirds approval from both houses of congress and approval by 38 states - a process very.
Getting rid of the electoral college means a vote is a vote, no matter where it is a vote in idaho is meaningless to a democratic candidate now, but it would be worth just as much as one in a swing state if we get rid of the electoral college. No the us electoral college is an appropriate federal-state-people power-sharing deal - the united states is not a pure, popular democracy the us constitution limits power between various entities, including the people, the federal government, and state governments. The elimination of the electoral college would be just another blow to the role of the states in the american system of government no longer would presidential candidates have to appeal to the farmers of rural iowa alongside the bankers of urban new york.